- End of the Road Boyz II Men
- Care of Cell 44 The Zombies
- No Diggity Blackstreet
- Girl, I Wanna Lay You Down Animal Liberation Orchestra
- Magic Ben Kweller
- Long Train Runnin' Doobie Brothers
- Cupcake Nellie McKay
- Knife Grizzly Bear
- Today Zero 7
- Perhaps, Perhaps, Perhaps Cake
This was the Knights core from 2005-2006. Some of these songs are still sung by the Knights.
- Amsterdam Guster
- The District Sleeps Alone Tonight The Postal Service
- Soul Meets Body Deathcab for Cutie
- Feel Good Inc. The Gorillaz
- Jesus, Etc Wilco
- Chicago Sufjan Stevens
- Hook Blues Traveler
- Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger Daft Punk
Songs always in the Knights' repertoire:
- If I Ever Fall in Love Shai
- MLK U2
- Steal Away Traditional
- It's You Barbershop
- Golden Times Knights Traditional
- Fair Carleton
- Mood Indigo
- Carleton Alma Mater
- The Star Spangled Banner Francis Scott Key
- Happy Birthday